INSTRUCTIONAL DESIGN Q471
Case Study 23
Sandra Hernandez
by John P. Campbell



Participating Group Members:
Mark Anderson
Lisa Bailey
Richard Butler
Robin Culbertson
Jennifer Farr
Nancy Turner  


Updated April 5, 2002 
 Contact Webmaster

 

The solutions suggested by the individuals in our group were excellent as evidenced on our Solutions page.  It was difficult narrowing our recommendations into one summary, but the majority of our group members did reach consensus in selecting the following solutions as our  top choices:

  • We agreed that software simulation software similar to  that found at http://www.eng-software.com/ and http://journal.fluid.power.net/issue4/software4.html  could be used to lighten the burden of setting up labs and would allow students to practice and reinforce various principals associated with the Engineering Course.  The cost of the software would be offset over time and would help save on the cost of expensive lab equipment.  The software could also be made more accessible to students since it could be loaded on campus lab computers.  Generally speaking, campus computers would be easier to access during odd and extended hours of the day than a real-life lab experiment would be.

  • We felt that Hernandez should begin the course with easier, hypothetical experiments and concepts and then progress to the more time-consuming  “real-world” experiments.  As a fairly new professor, it seemed possible that Hernandez did not have realistic expectations and this instructional approach could also incorporate the use of the simulation software.  It was noted by one group member and we all agreed, "real world designers use software before investing in expensive manufacturing materials." 

  • If Hernandez and Spaulding discovered that the problems experienced by Hernandez were typical (and possibly the reason that other instructors did not want to teach the course) there is a possibility that a prerequisite course, like Engineering Methods and Graphical Communications I should be offered.   If Spaulding determined the Engineering course too encompassing it might also be possible to break the one course into several more concentrated courses (example:  Introduction to Fluid Dynamics, Introduction to Electricity, Introduction to Force).  The creation of additional courses would in all probability lighten the student load as well.  Smaller groups of students would allow Hernandez time to devote to individuals and lesson preparation.

  • We also agreed that Hernandez might be able to utilize the graduate students more effectively by having them act as group leaders and lab assistants.  Using the graduate students would free Hernandez so she could provide more individual attention to her students and the students would also benefit from the added perspective the graduates might bring to the learning process.